We don't ask for your trust. We earn it — one fair transaction at a time. Here's what people who've sold their diamonds to us have to say.
"I felt completely safe and secure with my entire transaction. This is the best place I found in all of NYC to sell diamonds. The specialists took time to explain everything, and I walked away knowing I received a truly fair price. Highly recommend."
"I made appointments with several gold and diamond buyers to compare prices for four pieces of jewelry. Sell Diamonds NYC not only made me the best offer — they were by far the most professional. I walked away with cash in hand feeling treated completely fairly."
"I recommend coming here if you're looking to sell diamonds or fine jewelry. The team is knowledgeable, honest, and the process was completely stress-free. I received the highest offer I found anywhere in the city. Will return without hesitation."
"After my divorce, I needed to sell my engagement ring. I was nervous going in, but the team here treated me with so much kindness and respect. They explained the appraisal process fully and gave me an offer well above what two other buyers had quoted."
"Brought in my late mother's jewelry collection — a mix of diamond pieces, estate gold, and a Rolex. The specialists evaluated everything clearly, explained what they found, and gave me fair value for all of it. A very dignified experience."
"I'd been quoted very low prices elsewhere. Came to Sell Diamonds NYC and received 40% more than the highest competing offer. They clearly know diamonds inside and out. Will be recommending to everyone I know."
We've been buying diamonds in the New York Diamond District since the early 1990s. In an industry where trust is everything, our reputation is our most valuable asset — and we protect it in every transaction.
Every review you read reflects our core commitment: explain the evaluation, make the best offer we can, and treat the seller with the respect they deserve. No exceptions.
If you've had a great experience selling to us, we'd love to hear about it. Your review helps other sellers in New York find a buyer they can trust.
⭐ Leave a Google Review
Get a free, no-obligation diamond appraisal from the team NYC sellers trust most. Walk in or book an appointment today.